Welcome to the boards,
kellysixx! It's good to know one of us will be representin' at the Syracuse show!
I'm not very good at coming up with "creative fan gifts", but I have noticed something about past meet & greets. If you're planning on giving the gifts to Matt before the concert (at the buses), then I would say you should wear a fedora, so Matt notices you as HIS fan! I have read that Matt really turns up the charm when he sees a fan who wears a fedora or puts his name on a sign!
Heh, sounds pretty easy to get at least a hug from him! In addition to what you have, I would agree with
Lana, and say that anything DISNEY-RELATED would be memorable to Matt!
I hope that you get to meet him before the show because I have read that it is complete chaos (and too many people) AFTER the show. Matt will definitely have more time to appreciate your gifts before the concert, and he almost always comes out by the buses.
GOOD LUCK! I hope you get a hug!